Home/Compare/QuantPrompt vs Matriks and İdeal

QuantPrompt vs Matriks IQ and İdeal

Matriks IQ and İdeal are Turkish market-data and trading platforms with built-in strategy testing; QuantPrompt is a web tool only for testing strategies. Matriks and İdeal give you real-time BIST and VİOP data and send orders; QuantPrompt lets you write the rule as a Turkish sentence or as blocks, tests it on BIST and eight other markets, and checks whether the result is overfitted. Many traders test the idea in QuantPrompt and trade it in their terminal.

If you trade on Borsa Istanbul, Matriks and İdeal are the platforms you most likely already know. Both include backtesting, and both offer a way to build a strategy without code. This page compares them with QuantPrompt for one job: finding out whether a strategy idea holds up. Details about Matriks and İdeal come from product pages listed under Sources; prices and packages change, so check with the vendor or your broker.

Feature comparison

FeatureQuantPromptMatriks IQİdeal (İDEALGO)
What it isWeb app for testing strategy ideasDesktop data, analysis and trading terminalİdeal Data’s algorithmic trading product
Building a strategyA Turkish or English sentence, or rule blocksC# code, or wizard screens without codeNo-code builder (“without writing a single line of code”)
Backtest and optimizationYes; parameter plateau on the Max planYesYes, plus system and stock scanning
Overfitting checksWalk-forward, Monte Carlo, deflated Sharpe and stress, on every planNot stated in the sources we checkedNot stated in the sources we checked
MarketsBIST, plus US, India, Germany, Euronext, Shanghai and Japan stocks, crypto, forexBIST equities, VİOP, Binance spot and futuresTurkish markets; tracks spot–futures arbitrage
Real-time data and ordersNo: hourly to weekly bars from public sources, no order routingYes: a live data and trading terminalYes: automated trading robots based on price targets
AITurns your sentence into rules; analysis, critique and auto-iterateAI direction forecasts can be added to algorithmsNot stated in the sources we checked
Strategy as codeExport to Python, C++, Rust or JavaScriptAlgorithms are written in C# inside the platformNot stated in the sources we checked
PriceFree plan; paid plans $5, $15 and $49 a monthDepends on package and brokerDepends on package and broker

How are they different?

Matriks IQ is a desktop terminal you keep open all day: live prices, charts, market depth and trading, with algorithm testing and optimization built in. İdeal is a data platform whose İDEALGO adds no-code strategy testing and automated trading robots. Both are tools for trading on Borsa Istanbul, not only for testing.

QuantPrompt does one thing: it tests a strategy and tells you how much to trust the result. It runs in the browser, including on a phone, needs no installation and doesn't touch your brokerage account.

How do you build a strategy in each?

In Matriks IQ you write the algorithm in C#, or build it with wizard screens. İdeal's İDEALGO builds strategies and trading robots without code. Both are capable; both ask you to learn their builder.

In QuantPrompt you write the rule in Turkish, the way you would say it: “THYAO'da SuperTrend yukarı dönüp hacim ortalamanın üstündeyken al, 20 günlük Donchian dibinin altında kapanınca sat, %4 stop”. The rules it understood appear as blocks you can change, so nothing runs that you can't see. You can also build the whole strategy with blocks, choosing from 46 indicators, without any AI.

Can you trust the backtest?

A good-looking backtest is easy to get by trying enough variants. QuantPrompt's robustness test checks the result four ways: walk-forward testing on periods the parameters were not chosen on, a Monte Carlo reshuffle of your trades, the deflated Sharpe ratio, which corrects for the number of variants tried, and stress tests with double costs and each half of the period. Each is marked pass, caution or fail.

Matriks and İdeal both offer optimization, which finds the best parameters on past data. The product pages we checked don't describe out-of-sample or overfitting checks, so the best parameters they find are worth testing on data they haven't seen.

Which one should you use?

  • You need real-time BIST and VİOP data and order entry: Matriks IQ or İdeal
  • You want a strategy to trade itself on BIST: Matriks IQ or İdeal
  • You want to test an idea quickly by writing it in Turkish: QuantPrompt
  • You want to know whether a result is overfitted: QuantPrompt
  • You also test US, European, Asian, crypto or forex markets: QuantPrompt

They work well together: test and stress the idea in QuantPrompt, then trade the version that survived in the terminal you already use.

Frequently asked questions

Sources